New Labor Rule Clarifies Independent Contractor Status

Labor Department proposes returning to two-factor independent contractor test

The U.S. Department of Labor is proposing to replace the current federal standard for determining whether a worker is an employee or an independent contractor, putting greater weight on two factors: the company’s control over the work and the worker’s opportunity for profit or loss.

The Wage and Hour Division announced the proposed rule in late February 2026. The proposal would rescind the Biden-era framework adopted in 2024 and return to a “core factors” approach similar to the economic-reality guidance introduced during the first Trump administration.

A final rule is targeted for October 2026. Until a final rule is issued and takes effect, the proposal does not change the classification standards that apply under federal wage-and-hour law.

For professional truck drivers who operate under 1099 arrangements, lease equipment or work with multiple transportation companies, the change could affect how the working relationship is evaluated under the Fair Labor Standards Act. The central question would remain whether a driver is economically dependent on a business or is operating an independent business of their own.

Two factors would carry the most weight

Under the proposed test, the Department of Labor would give primary importance to the nature and degree of control exercised by the business and the worker’s opportunity for profit or loss based on managerial skill.

The control factor examines how the work is performed. It focuses on the actual relationship between the parties rather than only on language included in a contract. The analysis may consider the extent to which a business directs or controls the worker’s activities and the manner in which the work gets done.

The opportunity-for-profit-or-loss factor considers whether the worker can improve earnings through business decisions and managerial skill, or whether the worker’s income is largely determined by the company. The analysis also looks at whether the worker faces the possibility of losing money through those decisions.

For drivers, those questions could include how much practical control the driver has over the work and whether the driver can make business decisions that affect revenue or expenses. The proposed framework emphasizes actual practices, not merely what a contract says is theoretically permitted.

Four additional factors remain

The proposal would not eliminate the traditional factors used in worker-classification cases. It would continue to consider:

  • The worker’s investment in equipment and facilities;
  • The permanence of the working relationship;
  • The skill and initiative required to perform the work; and
  • Whether the work is integral to the business.

Those factors would still be part of the economic-reality analysis, but they would no longer carry equal weight with control and opportunity for profit or loss. The Department of Labor says elevating the two core factors would provide greater clarity and predictability when applying the test.

A shift from the 2024 framework

The 2024 rule used a six-factor, “totality-of-the-circumstances” analysis. Under that standard, the factors were generally considered together, with no factor designated as more important than the others. Additional considerations could be examined when relevant.

That framework replaced a rule adopted near the end of President Donald Trump’s first administration. The earlier approach also relied on an economic-reality test but treated control and the opportunity for profit or loss as the most probative factors.

The proposed rule would return to that structure while maintaining the broader inquiry into economic dependence. A worker is more likely to be considered an employee when the facts show economic dependence on the business. A worker is more likely to be considered an independent contractor when the facts show that the worker is in business for themselves.

What it could mean for truck drivers

The federal classification standard is important because employees generally receive protections under the Fair Labor Standards Act, including minimum-wage and overtime requirements. Independent contractors are treated as running their own businesses and are not covered in the same way by those wage-and-hour protections.

For trucking companies and drivers using 1099 arrangements, the proposed test would make the real-world details of the relationship especially important. A written independent-contractor agreement would be relevant, but the Department of Labor would place greater emphasis on how the parties actually operate.

The proposal does not establish a separate trucking-specific test. It applies to worker classification under the FLSA across industries, including businesses that use independent contractors, freelancers and gig workers.

It also would not automatically classify every driver in a 1099 arrangement as either an employee or an independent contractor. Instead, the classification would continue to depend on the economic realities of each working relationship, with control and the opportunity for profit or loss receiving the greatest weight.

The Department of Labor is expected to proceed through the federal rulemaking process before deciding whether to issue a final rule. Until then, the current 2024 framework remains the federal standard described in the proposal’s background.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply