Second Circuit Sides With New York in CDL Dispute
A unanimous panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit ruled that the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration improperly withheld approximately $73.5 million in federal highway funds from New York over the stateβs handling of non-domiciled commercial driverβs licenses.
Dispute centered on CDL expiration rules
The case involved commercial driverβs licenses issued to drivers who are not domiciled in the United States, including certain noncitizens who are lawfully present in the country.
At the time of the federal review, New York allowed newly issued non-domiciled CDLs to remain valid for up to five years. Renewed licenses could remain valid for as long as eight years. Federal officials later challenged the policy, arguing that the expiration dates should be tied to the driverβs authorized period of stay in the United States.
The dispute followed changes pushed by the U.S. Department of Transportation under Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy. Federal officials said the action was prompted by concerns that some licenses remained valid after a driver was no longer authorized to remain in the country.
Court rejects FMCSA funding penalty
New York challenged the federal determination directly in the Second Circuit, as required under federal law for disputes involving certain final decisions by the Department of Transportation.
In its ruling, the three-judge panel found that FMCSA acted in a manner that was βarbitrary, capricious, or contrary to lawβ when it penalized New York by withholding highway funds. The court concluded that the regulations in effect during the relevant period did not clearly require states to make a non-domiciled CDL expire on the same date as the holderβs authorized period of stay.
The decision requires the federal government to release approximately $73.5 million in highway funding that had been withheld from New York. The amount represented roughly 4% of the stateβs federal highway funding. Continued noncompliance could have exposed New York to the withholding of as much as $147 million in later years.
Implications for state CDL programs
The ruling provides short-term relief for New York and may affect how federal officials enforce updated requirements governing non-domiciled CDLs. The decision focused on whether FMCSA could apply the funding penalty under the regulations that were in effect when the licenses were issued.
States and federal regulators continue to face questions over how to align commercial licensing records with a driverβs immigration or authorized-stay status. The case also highlights the potential financial consequences for states whose CDL practices are found to conflict with federal requirements.