SCOTUS Revives Shipper and Receiver Liability After Montgomery Ruling

SCOTUS action revives shipper/receiver liability post-Montgomery

The U.S. Supreme Court has sent a California trucking accident case back to the state courts for reconsideration, reopening a dispute over whether shippers and freight recipients can use federal law to block state negligence and wrongful-death claims.

On Nov. 16, 2026, the court granted review in Casarez v. Irigoyen Farms Inc., No. 25-1421, vacated the published judgment from the California Court of Appeal and remanded the case “for further consideration in light of Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II, LLC.”

The order was a grant, vacate and remand, or GVR. That procedure does not resolve the underlying legal question. Instead, it wipes out the lower-court judgment and directs the state appellate court to reconsider the case in light of the Supreme Court’s recent decision in Montgomery.

The California court had previously held that the Federal Aviation Administration Authorization Act, commonly called the FAAAA, preempted direct negligence claims against Irigoyen Farms and Walmart. The Supreme Court’s action means that decision is no longer controlling in the case.

The crash and the parties

The case stems from a September 2019 fatal crash near Fresno, California. According to court filings, a truck carrying produce from Irigoyen Farms’ operations in Selma, California, to a Walmart distribution center in Nevada went through a stop sign and struck a car.

Olivia Mendoza died at the scene. The truck was driven by Andre Hill, an independent contractor who was later convicted of vehicular manslaughter and sentenced to two years in prison. Mendoza’s mother, Christina Casarez, brought the lawsuit.

The transportation arrangement involved several companies. Irigoyen Farms contracted with Royal Violet Logistics to arrange the shipment. Royal Violet then contracted with SIO Logistics, which hired Gold Coast Logistics as the motor carrier. Gold Coast hired Hill to drive the load.

Casarez sued entities connected to the shipment, including Irigoyen Farms and Walmart. The case materials state that Walmart was the intended recipient and did not select the broker, carrier or driver, maintain the truck, or otherwise participate in arranging transportation.

How the lower courts ruled

In September 2023, the Fresno County Superior Court granted summary judgment to Irigoyen Farms and Walmart, dismissing them from the lawsuit. The companies argued that the FAAAA preempted state claims that could affect transportation prices, routes or services.

They also argued that the law’s safety exception did not apply because they were not “motor vehicles.” The safety exception preserves certain state laws and claims “with respect to motor vehicles,” but the parties disagreed over how broadly that language should be applied.

The California Court of Appeal’s Fifth Appellate District affirmed the trial court’s decision in September 2025. The California Supreme Court declined to review the case in January 2026.

That ended the case in California for the time being, until the U.S. Supreme Court issued its decision in Montgomery. That ruling addressed whether the FAAAA safety exception could permit negligent-selection claims against freight brokers. The Supreme Court concluded that broker conduct could fall within the phrase “with respect to motor vehicles.”

Because the California courts had relied in part on reasoning that Montgomery later rejected, Casarez asked the U.S. Supreme Court to intervene. The court agreed to send the case back, but it did not decide whether Irigoyen Farms or Walmart can be held liable.

The unresolved legal question

The central issue now is whether FAAAA preemption can be asserted by defendants that are not specifically identified in the statute, including shippers and receivers farther up the supply chain.

The statute expressly addresses motor carriers and brokers, but it does not specifically identify shippers or freight recipients. Courts must determine whether those companies can invoke federal preemption when plaintiffs bring state-law claims alleging negligent selection, supervision or other conduct connected to a truck crash.

Attorney Gregory Reed, a partner with Hanson Bridgett who leads the firm’s transportation and logistics practice, described the case as an important shipper-receiver liability dispute. He also cautioned that the GVR order does not mean the Supreme Court has agreed to decide the broader issue.

“It is unclear whether the door is open for a monumental ruling,” Reed said, noting that the Supreme Court has so far declined to directly decide whether FAAAA preemption is available to shippers and receivers rather than brokers and motor carriers.

Reed also noted that no established split among federal appellate courts currently exists on the shipper and receiver question. Such a split helped prompt the Supreme Court’s review in Montgomery. The absence of a split could affect whether the justices later take up the issue after the California court acts again.

What happens next

The California Court of Appeal must reconsider Casarez in light of Montgomery. The court will revisit whether the claims against Irigoyen Farms and Walmart are preempted and whether the FAAAA safety exception permits the lawsuit to proceed.

The parties’ roles may also matter. Court filings indicate that Irigoyen Farms had a closer connection to the shipment and that Hill was present at the farm, where witnesses allegedly observed signs of fatigue. Walmart, by contrast, was the customer receiving the produce and said it had no role in selecting the transportation providers or driver.

The Supreme Court’s order does not alter any existing finding regarding Hill, the carrier or the other logistics companies involved in the shipment. It does, however, keep open the possibility that state courts could reconsider how liability is allocated among the companies connected to a load.

For drivers and carriers, the case is part of a broader legal debate over where responsibility ends for the motor carrier and begins for the broker, shipper or receiver. Until the California court issues a new decision, and possibly until other courts address the issue, the scope of FAAAA protection for those upstream parties remains unsettled.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply