Trucking Spot Rates Surge Despite Rising Fuel Costs

Trucking Spot Rates Defy Fuel Costs: An Unexpected Market Move
Dry van spot rates rose sharply ahead of the holiday shipping season even as diesel prices declined, creating an unusual split between trucking costs and freight prices. The move suggests that available capacity and a late-season inventory push are having a greater effect on the spot market than fuel expenses.
The National Truckload Index, or NTI, which measures all-in dry van spot rate movement across the United States, climbed more than 4% from late October into early November. Over the same period, average diesel prices at truck stops fell by roughly 3.5%.
The NTI reached its highest level since July during early November. Julie Van de Kamp, discussing data available Tuesday, Nov. 17, said the timing was unusual because the index typically does not begin a significant holiday-related climb so early in the month.
“It’s rare that the NTI starts jumping this early in November ahead of the holidays,” Van de Kamp said.
For professional drivers and carriers, the data reinforces an important distinction: fuel prices influence operating costs, but they do not automatically determine the rates available on individual loads. Spot rates are shaped primarily by the balance between freight demand and available trucks.
Because the NTI includes fuel, the recent divergence is especially notable. Diesel prices had not posted a sharp increase since early September, yet spot rates continued to move higher. In previous market cycles, fuel costs have risen while spot rates declined. The current pattern is moving in the opposite direction.
“Carriers can’t always pass those fuel costs along unless the market bears it,” Van de Kamp said. “And so we’ve also seen in prior cycles when fuel rates or costs have risen and spot rates have fallen, and we’re seeing the opposite right here.”
Late inventory push adds pressure
A last-minute effort by retailers to build holiday inventories appears to be one of the main factors behind the early rate increase. The October Logistics Manager Index recorded an inventory-level growth reading of 66.9, its highest level since 2022.
Many retailers delayed bringing holiday merchandise into the country because of uncertain demand, higher inventory carrying costs and more streamlined supply chains. That delay compressed the time available to move goods before the holiday selling season.
When a large volume of freight arrives late, some shipments move outside established transportation contracts and into the spot market. The spot market represents only about 10% to 25% of total truckload freight, depending on market conditions. Because it is a relatively small part of the overall market, even a modest increase in freight moving through spot channels can produce a noticeable rate change.
For drivers, that pressure can show up as more urgent pickup requests, shorter booking windows and increased demand for equipment in specific lanes. It may also create more imbalance between outbound and return freight, making the quality of the rate dependent on where the load leaves the truck rather than on the linehaul alone.
Capacity remains constrained
Dry van tender rejection rates have declined since July, but they remain between 10% and 15%. Rejection rates measure the share of contracted loads that carriers decline rather than accept at the offered rate.
Rejection rates above 10% are generally viewed as a sign that capacity remains insufficient. The current readings are not as extreme as the levels recorded during the summer, but they still indicate that carriers have some ability to choose freight that fits their networks.
Contract tender data and spot-rate data do not move in a one-to-one relationship. Contracted freight represents the much larger portion of truckload activity, while spot freight is the smaller and more volatile segment. As a result, rejection rates can fall while spot rates rise if late-arriving freight creates additional demand in a limited number of lanes.
Van de Kamp described the truckload market as still not fully recovered and said it remains in an unhealthy condition, although carriers retain meaningful flexibility heading into the holiday period.
Sharp moves instead of a steady recovery
Data on truckload rates excluding estimated fuel costs showed the same uneven pattern. The NTIL rose 8% during the two-week period from Nov. 19 through Dec. 4. That increase was slightly sharper than the moves recorded during the same period in the previous two years, when rates also rose around Thanksgiving but followed a slower path.
Last year’s rate movement began earlier and developed more gradually through late October and early November. Some market observers viewed that pattern as evidence of a broader recovery beyond normal seasonal demand. This year’s sharper jumps provide a different signal: carriers appear to be holding back on rate increases until market conditions make them necessary or practical.
That hesitation can make the market appear looser than it really is. When capacity tightens quickly or freight arrives in a concentrated surge, rates may move abruptly rather than gradually. The result is greater uncertainty for drivers, carriers and shippers planning freight around the holiday calendar.
The immediate lesson is that falling diesel prices do not necessarily translate into lower spot rates. For the current season, late inventory activity and limited available capacity are exerting more influence than fuel costs. The behavior of rejection rates and spot prices also indicates that the truckload market remains unsettled, with conditions capable of changing quickly as holiday freight moves through the system.